Stop Relying on Discounts: Smarter Ways to Increase Repeat Marketplace Sales

Everyone loves a good deal. But if discounts are the only way you can bring customers back, your margins—and your brand—will eventually pay the price. Discounts are easy. Loyalty? That takes strategy. For marketplace sellers trying to evolve into sustainable, recognizable brands, the race to the bottom isn’t just exhausting—it’s unnecessary.

Introduction

In a world where attention is expensive and loyalty is rare, discounts seem like a shortcut to retention. Flash sales. Coupon codes. BOGOs. They work—until they don’t. Because once customers expect discounts, you train them to wait. You shrink your profits. And worst of all, you reduce your value to a number with a percentage sign.

If you want to build something lasting, something worth talking about, you’ve got to shift your strategy. Let’s explore why it’s time to stop relying on discounts and dive into smarter, more sustainable ways to increase repeat sales.

The Discount Trap

Discounts feel good in the short term. But long term? They erode trust, brand equity, and pricing power. Here’s what over-discounting says to your customers:

• "Our products aren’t worth full price."
• "We’re always on sale, so wait for the next one."
• "We don’t value loyalty—just transactions."

Sure, there’s a time and place for discounts. But using them as your main retention tool is like using sugar to replace nutrition—it works, briefly, until it burns you out.

Smarter Ways to Increase Repeat Sales Without Discounts

1. Surprise and Delight

Instead of discounting for everyone, reward individuals in unexpected ways. A handwritten thank-you note. A freebie tucked in the box. A personalized email just checking in. It’s the stuff they don’t expect that gets remembered—and talked about.

2. Loyalty Programs That Reward More Than Purchases

Instead of just “buy more, earn points,” why not reward engagement too? Leave a review, follow on social, share a product—small actions that build brand love. Use tools like Yotpo or Privy to make it easy.

3. Create Useful Content

Start a newsletter. Share behind-the-scenes content. Offer advice that’s actually helpful. If your brand becomes a trusted voice—not just a seller—you stay top of mind without bribing people back.

4. Launch Limited Editions and Early Access

People crave exclusivity more than they crave discounts. Offer early access to new drops or create limited-run products. Scarcity creates urgency without killing your brand value.

5. Build a Brand Experience That’s Worth Repeating

Think beyond the product. Is your unboxing memorable? Are your follow-up emails friendly and relevant? Do customers feel appreciated and seen? That’s the stuff that brings them back.

6. Use Post-Purchase Automation

Smart emails can make or break loyalty. Use tools like Klaviyo or Omnisend to send:

• Product care tips
• Cross-sell suggestions
• Replenishment reminders (if applicable)
• Check-ins that don’t feel salesy

All without ever saying “20% off.”

The Psychology Behind Repeat Sales

Humans don’t just buy for utility. We buy for meaning, identity, and memory. When your brand gives people something to feel, they return. That’s not philosophy—it’s behavioral economics. Discounts reward the wallet. Experience rewards the heart.

What You Gain When You Stop Relying on Discounts

• Higher margins: No more giving away 15% of your revenue just to drive volume.
• More loyal customers: People who stick around for value, not deals.
• Stronger brand identity: You’re seen as premium, thoughtful, worth it.
• Predictable revenue: Loyal customers buy more frequently, without needing nudges.

FAQs

Is it ever okay to offer discounts?

Sure. Clearance, first-time buyers, or VIP thank-yous can work well. Just don’t make it your only lever. And never discount the stuff you want to be known for—it weakens the value story.

What if my competitors are discounting constantly?

That’s their race to lose. Compete on story, service, and substance. People will pay more for confidence, speed, and delight. Don’t play someone else’s game. Build your own field.

What’s the best tool to build a loyalty program?

Look into apps like LoyaltyLion or Smile.io. They integrate with Shopify and help you go beyond points-for-purchases.

Conclusion

If you want to sell more without selling out, stop leading with discounts. Build a brand people return to because it makes them feel something. Deliver value that isn’t always measured in percentages. Loyalty is earned, not bought—and that’s the long game worth playing.

Looking for bite-sized, practical tips to grow your multichannel business beyond discounts? Join our 30 Day Newsletter and start stacking small wins that lead to big results.